Note: I'm not talking about books that were turned into movies or television shows. I'm talking about the movie or show or play being turned into a novel, usually at the same time or shortly after the movie is coming out.
I just recently wrote a book review for West Side story and I've read most of the Star Wars novelizations, as well as Doctor Who. And I have noticed something. It's totally anecdotal, not a scientist or researcher here, but I feel like the books written for earlier media, say 60's or 70's, are varying levels of following the beat of the film to a letter. Some of the Doctor Who ones are almost the script basically. Better ones do try to do a bit more development, but they are pretty short and pacing ends up wonky. (Star Wars: Return of the Jedi is actually kind of memorable because it was written before George Lucas finalized some things so like Obi-Wan is Uncle Owen's brother in the book, not the film, and a few other details that just kind of throws you off.)
Later books, I'm thinking of specifically Star Wars Prequel novelizations, are for lack of better terms, legitimate books. Yes, they follow the plot of the movie, but they are so much more detailed and generally written much stronger. At least, in my opinion, they are.
So my question is, do you read the tie-in novels for media like that? Do you think they can or should be treated as a separate media or not? Do you even like them? (I do, when they are good. Some of the Doctor Who early novelizations were a total headache to read, especially as an ebook that messed up the formatting.)
- Back to HOL Forum Index Clubs and Departments Book Club Between the Pages
- Search
-
- It is currently Wed Apr 17, 2024 9:50 am
- All times are UTC+01:00
Movie Novel Tie Ins: Do You Like Them or Not?
Moderator: Book Club Heads
-
- Oakshaft 79
- Posts: 157
- Joined: Sat Jul 13, 2019 3:10 pm
Jump to
- Main Areas
- ↳ Announcements
- ↳ The Great Hall
- ↳ Ask a Prefect
- ↳ Admin Office
- Newspaper
- ↳ The Howler
- ↳ Guidelines & FAQ
- Classrooms
- ↳ General Class Discussions
- ↳ Classrooms
- ↳ Ancient Runes
- ↳ Apparition for Beginners
- ↳ Charms
- ↳ Guide to Shapeshifting
- ↳ Harry Potter: Family Studies
- ↳ Living with Dinosaurs
- ↳ Magic in Famous Mysteries
- ↳ Monsters in Cinema
- ↳ Muggle Studies: Hidden Powers
- ↳ Parseltongue: A Challenging Introduction
- ↳ Quidditch - The Wizarding Way
- ↳ Societies in Ruin
- ↳ The Battle of Hogwarts
- ↳ The Hobbit, From Tolkien to Jackson
- ↳ Wand-Making
- ↳ Werewolves 101
- ↳ Places and Magic
- ↳ And the Oscar Goes To, Take 1
- ↳ Disney Studies
- ↳ Care of Magical Pets
- ↳ Earth Magic
- ↳ Necromancy
- ↳ Astrology and Harry Potter
- ↳ Auror Training Levels One and Two
- ↳ History of Hogwarts: The Castle
- ↳ HOL Genetics
- ↳ Journey of the Hero
- ↳ Knitting the Muggle Way
- ↳ Patronus 101
- ↳ Pokemon Academy: The Basics
- ↳ Puzzles 101
- ↳ Seeking Fundamentals
- ↳ The Deathly Hallows
- ↳ The Marauders 101
- ↳ The Tudors
- ↳ History of Hogwarts: The Professors
- ↳ Mysteries of the Lake
- ↳ A Visit to Hogsmeade
- ↳ Potions
- ↳ Grindelwald's Crimes
- ↳ A Visit to Diagon Alley
- ↳ A History of Things
- ↳ Astronomy and Advanced Astronomy
- ↳ Defense Against the Dark Arts
- ↳ History of Hogwarts: The Founders
- ↳ Magical Beings
- ↳ Muggle Studies Pop Culture: The 80's
- ↳ Tour of the Common Rooms
- Clubs and Departments
- ↳ Quidditch
- ↳ Quidditch Handbook
- ↳ Art Department
- ↳ Library Department
- ↳ Book Club
- ↳ Book Teasers
- ↳ The Bookshelf
- ↳ Between the Pages
- ↳ Quill and Ink
- ↳ Ink Splatters
- ↳ Summer Poetry Festival
- Students' Lounge
- ↳ Discussions
- ↳ Book Talk
- ↳ Movie Talk
- ↳ Music Talk
- ↳ Sports Talk
- ↳ Games Talk
- ↳ TV Talk
- ↳ Harry Potter Talk
- ↳ Pottermore
- ↳ Cursed Child
- ↳ Fantastic Beasts
- ↳ Bulletin Board
- ↳ Care of Magical Pets
- ↳ Career Advice
- ↳ Fantastic Worlds and Where to Find Them
- ↳ Flying
- ↳ Healing Herbology
- ↳ HOL 101
- ↳ Magical Greek Mythology
- ↳ The History of Witchcraft
- ↳ Write Your World
- ↳ Harry Potter: Family Studies
- ↳ Magical Maladies
- ↳ Arithmancy
- ↳ Ancient Alchemy
- ↳ Advanced and Basic Care of Magical Creatures
- ↳ Divination
- ↳ Famous Witches and Wizards in History
- ↳ HOL Quidditch
- ↳ Muggles and Magic Collide
- ↳ Muggles and Magic II
- ↳ Norse Myths and Legends
- ↳ W.O.M.B.A.T.
- ↳ Muggle Studies for Beginners
- ↳ Potions For Beginners
- ↳ Occlumency
- ↳ Superhero Studies
- ↳ A Beginner's Guide to Villainy
- ↳ The AA Detective Agency
- ↳ Welcome Month
- ↳ Secret Elf Present Exchange
- ↳ Diagon Dealings
- ↳ The Dapper Dealmakers
- ↳ The Suave Sellers
- ↳ Jedi Apprentice Training
- ↳ Creature Card Corral
- ↳ Secret Elf 2022
- ↳ HOLTS Activities
- ↳ Triwizard Tournament
- ↳ HOLLERS
- ↳ Announcements
- ↳ Challenges
- ↳ The Scrapbook
- ↳ The Scrapbook Archive
- ↳ Creative Outlet
- ↳ Writing Under Constraint
- ↳ Creature Card Corral