Doctor Who!
Moderator: Prefects
-
Sophia Rudel
- No broom
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Sun Aug 07, 2011 12:53 pm
Re: Doctor Who!
My first was Eccleston too. I'll always have a soft spot for Nine (you never forget your first Doctor!) I liked when Tennant took over, although I cried so much when he and Rose were separated to the parallel worlds and then a lot more when he regenerated. I loved Matt Smith's doctor. He could be so playful and then so vicious. I loved watching his doctor with River Song! As much as I love my Doctors she is one of my favorite characters. If you haven't had the chance I would recommend the original Doctors especially the Fourth. My favorites of his are The Ark in Space and the Deadly Assassin.
Practice Random Acts of Reading
-
Prof. Maxim Trevelyan
- Nimbus 1001
- Posts: 2362
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 7:35 pm
Re: Doctor Who!
Third time is the charm?
As some may know, I have a love-hate relationship with Doctor Who series, which may be surprising, considering I loved Torchwood (until Children of Earth that is...
).
I loved Eccleston as a Doctor, but stopped watching after Rose stopped being a companion. Tried some episodes without her , but the cast just did not have the same energy for me. I resumed on Sky's urging three or so years ago, same result.
However, I love, love, love Jodie Whittaker as the Doctor. Female Doctor (and the 13th Doctor series in general) is very polarizing, but I just love it. Sure, some ideas might be bit too out there, but I love her acting, her interpretation of the doctor, the companions, everything.
So, I decided to give the 2005 series another try. Maybe this time I will make it past my record?
As some may know, I have a love-hate relationship with Doctor Who series, which may be surprising, considering I loved Torchwood (until Children of Earth that is...
I loved Eccleston as a Doctor, but stopped watching after Rose stopped being a companion. Tried some episodes without her , but the cast just did not have the same energy for me. I resumed on Sky's urging three or so years ago, same result.
However, I love, love, love Jodie Whittaker as the Doctor. Female Doctor (and the 13th Doctor series in general) is very polarizing, but I just love it. Sure, some ideas might be bit too out there, but I love her acting, her interpretation of the doctor, the companions, everything.
So, I decided to give the 2005 series another try. Maybe this time I will make it past my record?

...also a platonic soulmate and a hot mess of a human being.
-
Cassiopia Smith
- No broom
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Tue Sep 05, 2023 10:26 pm
Re: Doctor Who!
I'm not what you'd consider a avid doctor who fan but as a fan of both David Tennant and Catherine Tate I really enjoyed the show when they were both on it 
-
Emily Spencer
- Nimbus 1000
- Posts: 2074
- Joined: Wed Jul 10, 2019 6:25 pm
Re: Doctor Who!
Sadly, I haven't watched Doctor Who in a few years now. For me, the story began to unravel when Jodie Whitaker took over the role. Now don't get me wrong, I love Jodie as an actress, but she just never quite felt right for this particular role. She came across as blundering and a bit too glib for my liking. Then Chibnall took it in an entirely out-of-left-field direction and basically destroyed the whole history of the show. I'm not sure if I will pick it up again or not. My favorite Doctor, however, still is Matt Smith.

Slytherin Head Prefect/Student Teacher/Co-Head Library/Art/Book Club
-
Alexandra Starling
- No broom
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Sun Sep 17, 2023 9:01 pm
Re: Doctor Who!
I'm a bit late to this, but I absolutely adore the show. unfortunately I haven't been able to watch past Season 12 (Jodie Whittaker's one). Unfortunately they've removed it from Amazon Prime and BBC where I live, so all my updates are form social media
. But oh, I've cried and laughed watching this show. Absolutely amazing!
-
Maeve Madden
- No broom
- Posts: 94
- Joined: Mon Feb 01, 2021 5:59 pm
Re: Doctor Who!
I just started watching it over again a few days ago! I kept seeing a bunch of buzz about the new episodes, and since I stopped watching after Matt Smith's Doctor, this was the perfect excuse to start the show over again. I grew up on Doctor Who so I'm pretty excited to watch it again.
My favourite Doctor is David Tennant for sure, with Matt Smith coming in a close second. Although, being on Eccleston's season, he's definitely growing on me a lot.
My favourite Doctor is David Tennant for sure, with Matt Smith coming in a close second. Although, being on Eccleston's season, he's definitely growing on me a lot.
-
Emily Spencer
- Nimbus 1000
- Posts: 2074
- Joined: Wed Jul 10, 2019 6:25 pm
Re: Doctor Who!
I haven't really watched, sadly, since the middle of Jodie's run. I say sadly because I am a lifelong fan of the show. My favorite Doctor is Smith, hands down. Tennant was brilliant as well, but Smith had me before his first episode ended.

Slytherin Head Prefect/Student Teacher/Co-Head Library/Art/Book Club
-
Janne Halla
- Cleansweep One
- Posts: 612
- Joined: Sun Jul 31, 2022 6:23 pm
Re: Doctor Who!
I'm not a big Doctor Who enjoyer, but the kids seem to love it (the more light-hearted episodes, that is).
They simply love the Ncuti Gatwa run, I haven't seen them so excited about a show before (except Bluey and Moomins). The sillier the episode seems, the more they love it. Space Babies was a hit, while it was definitely the weakest of that season for me.
I preferred the Jodie Whittaker and David Tennant runs myself, but since I'm a casual fan, I can really find enjoyment in any of the episodes, to be honest. I find that they have an excellent representation of marginalized groups. They conduct their research well, at least in the more modern seasons, which is always a welcome thing to see.
They simply love the Ncuti Gatwa run, I haven't seen them so excited about a show before (except Bluey and Moomins). The sillier the episode seems, the more they love it. Space Babies was a hit, while it was definitely the weakest of that season for me.
I preferred the Jodie Whittaker and David Tennant runs myself, but since I'm a casual fan, I can really find enjoyment in any of the episodes, to be honest. I find that they have an excellent representation of marginalized groups. They conduct their research well, at least in the more modern seasons, which is always a welcome thing to see.

Thank you, Prof. Aloyarc, for the signature!
-
Emily Spencer
- Nimbus 1000
- Posts: 2074
- Joined: Wed Jul 10, 2019 6:25 pm
Re: Doctor Who!
My favorite Doctor would have to be Matt Smith, though I did enjoy most of Tennant’s run as well. I did grow weary of the whole Doctor/Rose soap opera, so that rather marred Tennant a bit for me.

Slytherin Head Prefect/Student Teacher/Co-Head Library/Art/Book Club